Friday Night Fights [Round 40]

Welcome back fight fans, to Sin City Nevada for another shanghai edition of Friday Night Fights! This week’s bout is the battle of the shipwrights, with at least a month’s worth of bragging rights and and a dram of top-shelf whiskey on the line.   Tonight’s bout is a little unusual in that the fighters in question recently challenged each other to see who could come up with the most accurate model of the Japanese Maritime Self-Defense Force’s Asagiri class destroyer from the mid 1980’s.  The rules were simple: the Asagiri would be built in 1:350 scale, using only parts that are available IRL. The match-up has some added importance in my mind, because these guys went out of their way to challenge each other and they are not currently getting any help from the community to resolve the challenge.  The handful of comments is typically weak, never more than a sentence and avoids the topic of comparison entirely.  Let’s do these gents a solid and determine the winner here, on the blood-stained floors of the Manifesto arena.

Without further preamble, let’s go to the tale of the tape.

DD-158-Umigiri-002

Fighting out of the red corner, from a long patrol somewhere in the Sea of Japan,  it’s Mark “The Machete” B. and his “JDS Asagiri (DD-151)”.

29510925058_050498305a_o.png

And fighting out of the blue corner, from the top of a swell in the East China Sea, it’s “Lock and Load” Locutus666 and his “JDS Asagiri DD-151“.

JDS Asagiri DD-151

As usual, constant reader, you are tasked with deciding the outcome of this pugilistic endeavor and determine who will receive a week’s worth of bragging rights. Simply leave a comment below and vote for the model that best suits your individual taste. I will tally up the votes next Friday and declare a winner.

Last time, on Friday Night Fights….

It was the battle of the big rock candy mountain, with a bottle of hooch and a bulging bindle of SWAG on the line.  In the end, David “MagnetoZambito and his “Country Side Tunnel took his opponent to the woodshed with a bruising 14-3 victory over Jason “The Axeman” Allemann  and his “Moutain Train“. Zambito scores his first victory (1-0) while Allemann runs his record to (0-1).

40310783811_1b6d1cc2a9_o

14 thoughts on “Friday Night Fights [Round 40]

  1. The shaping on the front seems more in scale for Mark’s, Locutus’ feels a stud or two short. Mark’s extensive details like the curved slopes making up the face of the bridge and his black tower are superb. Love the wall pieces on their sides that form the hilo deck.

    Definitely Mark.

    Like

  2. Mark “The Machete” B. It appears they are both digital builds (unless my eyes deceive me) which makes Locutus’s choices all the more questionable and disappointing. “You had EVERYTHING!”… Odd mix of the dark grey and that white stripe across the side. Also the use of that fence panel part at the back seems lazy. Don’t think the person spent much time refining it in any way… reminds me of my very first LDD train build in that way, ages and ages ago. Like me, hope they take the critique and improve.

    Like

  3. I’m usually one to downplay NPU, but part usage is vital when working at this small a scale. Mark B. makes each element look distinctly functional with the parts he’s chosen, while in Locutus’s the details of the original ship feel lost in a salad of plate offsets and bars. Another vote for the red corner.

    Like

  4. Also, I didn’t factor this into how I voted, but I find it kind of jarring to use a photo background on a digital MOC, especially if it hasn’t been through a renderer.

    Like

  5. I’m also throwing my vote Mark’s way. Despite both having the same source material, Mark has absolutely nailed the shaping, and no part has gone to waste. My favourite things about it is the way he’s shaped the front of the hull, the black steel communication tower and the 10 or so ‘corner’ pieces at the rear of the boat. It all blends together brilliantly.

    Locutus build, by comparison, seems a tad too blocky for a realistic ship, and I feel that some of the colour choices aren’t the best suited for the job; the dark grey and white stripe for example. That being said, I do appreciate the Japanese flag and the rapier parts as aerials.

    Overall though, Mark’s is the better build.

    Like

  6. Mark B hands down. The forward gun is proportional. The bow has a better shape, and the forward tower is superior. The radomes and Phalanxes are better represented, and the deck under the helipad and hangar just looks more thought out. I was never a fan of those fence pieces except for SNOT. The Seahawk on the stern is the icing on the cake.

    Locutus666 gets a point for showing the rest of the hull below the waterline and the propeller, but in Lego ship building, I don’t really the point of doing this. It makes display difficult because you usually have to build a stand for it, and it doesn’t fit in diorama, and it’s just not typically seen unless you have the ship drydocked.

    Like

  7. Although Locutus’ rendering looks realistic enough, the ship is rather messy and the hull seems flat.So, my vote goes to Mark.

    Like

  8. My vote has gotta go to Mark. Both paid close attention to not miss details of the ship, but I tend to enjoy Mark’s part usage more; seems truer to the inspiration. The curvature of the hull also has a huge impact on my decision.

    Like

    1. Never too late until the next match-up I think. Hopefully Keith will have another for us soon. I know Ted has been teasing a new article on his Flickr as of late…

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s